What do Michigan Auto Workers Think About USMCA? - Paycheck

What do Michigan Auto Workers Think About USMCA?

Would Michiganders benefit if the USMCA (the Trump administration’s renegotiated successor to the North American Free Trade Agreement NAFTA) is approved by Congress? Ask the people who have been paying attention, like Michigan-based automakers and their unions, and the answer is clear as mud. Automakers and suppliers, who spent years defending NAFTA against attacks from Democrats and, more recently, candidate and president Donald Trump, have come out in support of USMCA, appearing on a panel here last month with Vice President Mike Pence to tout the deal. But maybe not quite unabashedly. The Michigan Manufacturing Association, which co-hosted the Pence visit, is mostly concerned with preserving “free and fair trade” in an export market that is “the bread and butter” of the industry, said its vice president of government affairs Mike Johnston. But his members aren’t saying much in the wake of the visit. A spokesman for Magna International, the giant parts maker whose CEO participated in the panel, said last week the company is “laying low on the trade and tariff discussion right now,” and declined further comment. The unions and Democratic supporters of labor in Congress, on the other hand, have - after several decades of complaining that NAFTA needed to be reworked to include higher requirements for North American content in vehicles covered by the pact and mandates for better pay and working conditions for Mexican workers, both of which are included in the USMCA - are mostly opposed. In other words, some people were for a new North American trade deal before they were against it. And vice versa. Which is understandable on an issue so convoluted and complex that a quarter century after its enactment there is no ​consensus​ on whether NAFTA was good for Michigan and American workers in the first place. Chris Vitale, a 25-year member of the UAW in Michigan and 3rd generation employee at Chrysler (now Fiat Chrysler), says that, to most people he knows, the details of international trade are just “too boring, too many numbers. Their eyes glaze over.” Vitale says he is inclined to credit ​claims​ like those from Vice President Pence that 76,000 new American jobs could be created in the auto sector under USMCA. And there is some ​evidence that the new administration’s trade posture is promoting investment in the U.S. Vitale says he also believes the new standards in USMCA for Mexican wages would benefit workers on both sides of the southern border by protecting Americans from low-wage competition and ensuring higher living standards for Mexican autoworkers. “Donald Trump could end up doing more to create a Mexican middle class than anybody in Mexico,” he says. In Vitale’s view, American trade policy has been “virtually a giveaway by our country” for most of the time since WWII. Negotiators always talked about a level playing field but never delivered one for American workers, he says. “We acted like the heavyweight that never throws a punch and gets done in by a lightweight.” But you can’t call Vitale sanguine about the prospects for USMCA. The political atmosphere is too toxic, he says. Its opponents are too committed to the resistance.
Dawson Bell

Related Articles

Farm consolidation, pandemic contributing to rising food costs

August 4, 2021

As consumers continue to see rising food prices in the grocery stores and at their favorite restaurants, many wonder what’s going on

Read more

What the opioid settlement means for Wisconsin

August 4, 2021

According to a report by the Wisconsin Department of Health Services, 1,100 Wisconsinites died last year due to opioid abuse.

Read more

How Pennsylvanians Feel About The Current State Of The Pandemic

July 28, 2021

With a year and a half into the COVID-19 Pandemic, the light at the end of the tunnel started to shine.

Read more
Category Sidebar

Thanks for signing the pledge! Click here to share this on Facebook.

By using this website, you automatically accept that we use cookies.